At this performance

The Great Gatsby

Broadway Theatre

8 cast changes

  • Jonathan Young as Jay Gatsby

    Usually Ryan McCartan

    Jonathan Young Broadway debut! National tours: Les Misérables, Pretty Woman. Selected regional: 1776 (Paper Mill Playhouse), Austen’s Pride (ACT of CT) An American in Paris (Westchester Broadway). TV: “The Gilded Age.” Endless gratitude to my family, Solstice, the Gatsby team and Jack.

  • Sara Sheperd as Myrtle Wilson

    Usually Linedy Genao

    Sara Sheperd Broadway: Beautiful: The Carole King Musical (u/s Carole, OBC), Paradise Square, Cry-Baby. National tours: Beautiful (Carole King), Legally Blonde (Kate/Chutney). Others: Beautiful (Carole, Muny), Cats (Grizabella, The Fulton), Funny Girl (Fanny Brice, Drury Lane). TV: “The Gilded Age,” “Law & Order.” Presidential Scholar in the Arts. CCM grad. @shepnailsi

  • Dave Schoonover as Meyer Wolfsheim

    Usually Eric Anderson

    Dave Schoonover Broadway: Bad Cinderella (Dorian). Pre-Broadway: A Wonderful World. Tours: Love Never Dies (u/s Phantom, Raoul), White Christmas (Sheldrake, u/s Bob), Young Frankenstein (u/s Dr. Frankenstein), Cats (Tugger). NYC: Carnegie Hall, City Center. Regional: Lots. Love to Rachel and Levi. @schoonyman

  • Drew Lake as Catherine

    Drew Lake Broadway debut! Selected credits: The Great Gatsby (Korea), The Cher Show (tour), Bat Out of Hell (Las Vegas). Love to my 3 Ms & Nonnie always. Gigantic thanks to Jim at MTA & the entire Gatsby team. “Just do it!” @idrewalake

  • Emily Anne Nester as Sugar

    Emily Anne Nester Broadway debut! International: The Great Gatsby (Korea). Tour: Funny Girl. Endless love and gratitude to my Mom and Dad, Mac, Jord, family and friends. Thank you to my agents at CESD and the entire Gatsby team! Dream big! @emilyannenester

  • Kurt Csolak as Ensemble

    Kurt Csolak Broadway: Funny Girl (Ensemble, u/s Nick Arnstein). Theatre: Encores! The Tap Dance Kid, Ayodele Casel’s Chasing Magic, Dorrance Dance, 42nd Street, Tap Dogs. TV/film: “The Performance,” “Speed Racer.” NYU grad. Love to Mom, Amy, family, mentors and friends! @kurtcsolak

  • Morgan Harrison as Ensemble

    Morgan Harrison is thrilled to be joining the Gatsby party! Broadway: Beetlejuice, Mean Girls. Tour: Beetlejuice, Mean Girls, Flashdance. TV: “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel.” All my love to Mama, Gram, Captain, Brian from HKA and this entire cast and crew! Hebrews 6:19

  • Justin Keats as Ensemble

    Justin Keats “Keats” The bespectacled. Broadway: Paramour, Escape to Margaritaville. Tour: Moulin Rouge! NYC: Radio City Christmas Spectacular, MSG, Carnegie Hall. Regional: Muny, La Jolla Playhouse, Pioneer, Music Circus. Disney Entertainment. BFA: UCI. Love to Donna & Jacque! Thanks agent Dave! @ForKeatsSake

The slip

The insert that would have been tucked into the program that night. Print it, or open it in the slip maker to change the wording.

Edit in slip maker

The Great Gatsby

At this performance

The role of Jay Gatsby will be played by Jonathan Young

The role of Myrtle Wilson will be played by Sara Sheperd

The role of Meyer Wolfsheim will be played by Dave Schoonover

The role of Catherine will be played by Drew Lake

The role of Sugar will be played by Emily Anne Nester

The role of Ensemble will be played by Kurt Csolak

The role of Ensemble will be played by Morgan Harrison

The role of Ensemble will be played by Justin Keats

Broadway Theatre Monday, November 16, 2026, 7:00 PM

Based on published cast-change announcements from At This Playbill, last read on Nov 19, 2026. Not every performance or change is recorded. Spotted a mistake or a missing change? Email support@theatreview.app with the show and date.