Stranger Things: The First Shadow
At this performance
The role of Principal Newby will be played by Stephen Wattrus
The role of Sue Anderson will be played by Maya West
The roles usually played by Nya Garner will be played by Rebecca Hurd
Marquis Theatre
Stephen Wattrus as Principal Newby
Usually Andrew Hovelson
Stephen Wattrus is grateful to be back on Broadway with this incredible cast. Broadway: Take Me Out (Second Stage). Collaborations with New York Theatre Workshop, Williamstown Theatre Festival. Much love to his family, wife and agents for their unwavering support.
Maya West as Sue Anderson
Usually Zoe Sage
Maya West Broadway debut! Born and raised in New York, Maya is a proud alumna of LaGuardia High School. She’s currently pursuing a BFA in theatre and performance at Emerson College. Endless thanks and love to her mom and dad.
Rebecca Hurd covering Nya Garner’s roles
Rebecca Hurd Broadway debut. Off-Broadway: Boswell. Regional: Relentless (TimeLine/Goodman), An Enemy of the People (Goodman), Beautiful: The Carole King Musical (Paramount), Stage Kiss (Guthrie), among others. Thanks to Stewart and the Stranger Things family. For M&D and Nat. @rebeccadidhear
The insert that would have been tucked into the program that night. Print it, or open it in the slip maker to change the wording.
Stranger Things: The First Shadow
At this performance
The role of Principal Newby will be played by Stephen Wattrus
The role of Sue Anderson will be played by Maya West
The roles usually played by Nya Garner will be played by Rebecca Hurd
Based on published cast-change announcements from At This Playbill, last read on Nov 18, 2026. Not every performance or change is recorded. Spotted a mistake or a missing change? Email support@theatreview.app with the show and date.