Cast history

Stranger Things: The First Shadow cast changes and understudies

Marquis Theatre · Apr 22, 2025 – Jan 3, 2027

44 performances documented between Oct 16, 2026 and Nov 22, 2026. 42 performances had at least one announced change, 185 changes in all.

October 2026

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12
  13. 13
  14. 14
  15. 15
  16. 16
  17. 17
  18. 18
  19. 19
  20. 20
  21. 21
  22. 22
  23. 23
  24. 24
  25. 25
  26. 26
  27. 27
  28. 28
  29. 29
  30. 30
  31. 31

November 2026

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12
  13. 13
  14. 14
  15. 15
  16. 16
  17. 17
  18. 18
  19. 19
  20. 20
  21. 21
  22. 22
  23. 23
  24. 24
  25. 25
  26. 26
  27. 27
  28. 28
  29. 29
  30. 30

Cast changes Cast as printed Nothing on record

  1. Sunday, November 22, 2026

    • Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles

    • Malcolm Callender select Roles of Sean Mikesh

    Bios and cast slip for Sun, Nov 22, 1:00 PM →
  2. Saturday, November 21, 2026

    • Stephen Wattrus as Chief Hopper/Captain Brenner

      Usually Ted Koch

    • Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Nov 21, 1:00 PM →

    • Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Nov 21, 7:00 PM →
  3. Friday, November 20, 2026

    • Kelsey Anne Brown as Joyce Maldonado

      Usually Shea Grant

    • Rebecca Hurd covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles

    • Stephen Wattrus as Chief Hopper/Captain Brenner

      Usually Ted Koch

    • Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles

    • Ben Ashcraft select Roles of Sean Mikesh

    • Sean Mikesh select Roles of Ben Ashcraft

    Bios and cast slip for Fri, Nov 20, 7:00 PM →
  4. Thursday, November 19, 2026

    • Lia Christina as Alice Creel

      Usually Francesca Yhlen

    • Stephen Wattrus as Chief Hopper/Captain Brenner

      Usually Ted Koch

    • Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles

    • Rebecca Hurd covering Nya Garner’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Thu, Nov 19, 7:00 PM →
  5. Wednesday, November 18, 2026

    • Nya Garner as Patty Newby

      Usually Ayana Cymone

    • Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles

    • Stephen Wattrus as Chief Hopper/Captain Brenner

      Usually Ted Koch

    • Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Wed, Nov 18, 7:00 PM →
  6. Tuesday, November 17, 2026

    • Nya Garner as Patty Newby

      Usually Ayana Cymone

    • Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles

    • Justin Adams as Chief Hopper/Captain Brenner

      Usually Ted Koch

    • Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles

    • Drew Redington as Alan Munson

      Usually Ben Ashcraft

    Bios and cast slip for Tue, Nov 17, 7:00 PM →
  7. Sunday, November 15, 2026

    • Logan Gould as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Ben Ashcraft as Bob Newby

      Usually Juan Carlos

    • Neil McCaffrey as Alan Munson

      Usually Ben Ashcraft

    • Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Sun, Nov 15, 1:00 PM →

    • Logan Gould as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Ben Ashcraft as Bob Newby

      Usually Juan Carlos

    • Neil McCaffrey as Alan Munson

      Usually Ben Ashcraft

    • Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Sun, Nov 15, 7:00 PM →
  8. Saturday, November 14, 2026

    • Ben Ashcraft as Bob Newby

      Usually Juan Carlos

    • Neil McCaffrey as Alan Munson

      Usually Ben Ashcraft

    • Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Logan Gould as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles

    • Malcolm Callender select Roles of Sean Mikesh

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Nov 14, 1:00 PM →

    • Logan Gould as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Ben Ashcraft as Bob Newby

      Usually Juan Carlos

    • Neil McCaffrey as Alan Munson

      Usually Ben Ashcraft

    • Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles

    • Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Nov 14, 7:00 PM →
  9. Friday, November 13, 2026

    Cast as printed in the Playbill program.

  10. Thursday, November 12, 2026

    • Ben Ashcraft as Bob Newby

      Usually Juan Carlos

    • Drew Redington as Alan Munson

      Usually Ben Ashcraft

    • Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Malcolm Callender as Charles Sinclair

      Usually Robert T. Cunningham

    • Tom D'Agustino as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Thu, Nov 12, 7:00 PM →
  11. Wednesday, November 11, 2026

    • Nya Garner as Patty Newby

      Usually Ayana Cymone

    • Rebecca Hurd covering Nya Garner’s roles

    • Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Malcolm Callender as Charles Sinclair

      Usually Robert T. Cunningham

    Bios and cast slip for Wed, Nov 11, 7:00 PM →
  12. Tuesday, November 10, 2026

    • Malcolm Callender as Charles Sinclair

      Usually Robert T. Cunningham

    • Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Kelsey Anne Brown as Claudia Yount

      Usually Afra Sophia Tully

    • Maya West covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles

    • Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson

      Usually Thatcher Jacobs

    Bios and cast slip for Tue, Nov 10, 7:00 PM →
  13. Sunday, November 8, 2026

    • Thatcher Jacobs as Henry Creel

      Usually Victor de Paula Rocha

    • Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson

      Usually Thatcher Jacobs

    • Maya West as Sue Anderson

      Usually Zoe Sage

    • Malcolm Callender as Charles Sinclair

      Usually Robert T. Cunningham

    • Drew Redington covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Sun, Nov 8, 1:00 PM →

    • Malcolm Callender as Charles Sinclair

      Usually Robert T. Cunningham

    • Drew Redington covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    • Maya West as Sue Anderson

      Usually Zoe Sage

    Bios and cast slip for Sun, Nov 8, 7:00 PM →
  14. Saturday, November 7, 2026

    • Maya West as Sue Anderson

      Usually Zoe Sage

    • Rebecca Hurd covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles

    • Drew Redington other Roles Played By…

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Nov 7, 1:00 PM →

    • Thatcher Jacobs as Henry Creel

      Usually Victor de Paula Rocha

    • Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson

      Usually Thatcher Jacobs

    • Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles

    • Nya Garner as Sue Anderson

      Usually Zoe Sage

    • Rebecca Hurd covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles

    • Rebecca Hurd covering Nya Garner’s roles

    • Drew Redington other Roles Played By…

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Nov 7, 7:00 PM →
  15. Friday, November 6, 2026

    • Kala Ross as Patty’s Mom

      Usually Ta’Rea Campbell

    • Janie Brookshire covering Kala Ross’s roles

    • Maya West as Sue Anderson

      Usually Zoe Sage

    Bios and cast slip for Fri, Nov 6, 7:00 PM →
  16. Thursday, November 5, 2026

    • Maya West as Sue Anderson

      Usually Zoe Sage

    • Stephen Wattrus as Principal Newby

      Usually Andrew Hovelson

    Bios and cast slip for Thu, Nov 5, 7:00 PM →
  17. Wednesday, November 4, 2026

    • Maya West as Sue Anderson

      Usually Zoe Sage

    Bios and cast slip for Wed, Nov 4, 7:00 PM →
  18. Tuesday, November 3, 2026

    • Stephen Wattrus as Principal Newby

      Usually Andrew Hovelson

    • Maya West as Sue Anderson

      Usually Zoe Sage

    • Rebecca Hurd covering Nya Garner’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Tue, Nov 3, 7:00 PM →
  19. Sunday, November 1, 2026

    • Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel

      Usually Nick Rehberger

    • Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson

      Usually Thatcher Jacobs

    • Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    • Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Sun, Nov 1, 1:00 PM →

    • Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel

      Usually Nick Rehberger

    • Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson

      Usually Thatcher Jacobs

    • Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    • Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Sun, Nov 1, 7:00 PM →
  20. Saturday, October 31, 2026

    • Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel

      Usually Nick Rehberger

    • Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson

      Usually Thatcher Jacobs

    • Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Oct 31, 1:00 PM →

    • Rebecca Hurd as Virginia Creel

      Usually Rosie Benton

    • Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel

      Usually Nick Rehberger

    • Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson

      Usually Thatcher Jacobs

    • Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Oct 31, 7:00 PM →
  21. Friday, October 30, 2026

    • Zoe Sage as Patty Newby

      Usually Ayana Cymone

    • Maya West as Sue Anderson

      Usually Zoe Sage

    • John Patrick Collins as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson

      Usually Thatcher Jacobs

    • Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Fri, Oct 30, 7:00 PM →
  22. Thursday, October 29, 2026

    • John Patrick Collins as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Thu, Oct 29, 7:00 PM →
  23. Wednesday, October 28, 2026

    • John Patrick Collins as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Wed, Oct 28, 7:00 PM →
  24. Tuesday, October 27, 2026

    • John Patrick Collins as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Tom D'Agustino as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Rebecca Hurd as Karen Childress

      Usually Taylor Sage Evans

    • Neil McCaffrey as Alan Munson

      Usually Ben Ashcraft

    • Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Tue, Oct 27, 7:00 PM →
  25. Sunday, October 25, 2026

    • Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles

    • Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Sun, Oct 25, 1:00 PM →

    • Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles

    • Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Sun, Oct 25, 7:00 PM →
  26. Saturday, October 24, 2026

    • Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel

      Usually Nick Rehberger

    • Rebecca Hurd as Karen Childress

      Usually Taylor Sage Evans

    • Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles

    • Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Oct 24, 1:00 PM →

    • Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel

      Usually Nick Rehberger

    • Rebecca Hurd as Karen Childress

      Usually Taylor Sage Evans

    • Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles

    • Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Oct 24, 7:00 PM →
  27. Friday, October 23, 2026

    • Rebecca Hurd as Karen Childress

      Usually Taylor Sage Evans

    • Lauren Nicole Cipoletti as Claudia Yount

      Usually Afra Sophia Tully

    • Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Fri, Oct 23, 7:00 PM →
  28. Thursday, October 22, 2026

    • Rebecca Hurd as Karen Childress

      Usually Taylor Sage Evans

    • Maya West covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles

    • Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Thu, Oct 22, 7:00 PM →
  29. Wednesday, October 21, 2026

    Cast as printed in the Playbill program.

  30. Tuesday, October 20, 2026

    • Janie Brookshire as Virginia Creel

      Usually Rosie Benton

    • Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Rebecca Hurd covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles

    Bios and cast slip for Tue, Oct 20, 7:00 PM →
  31. Sunday, October 18, 2026

    • Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.

      Usually Matthew Erick White

    • Rebecca Hurd as Claudia Yount

      Usually Afra Sophia Tully

    • Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles

    • Thatcher Jacobs other Roles Played By…

    • Ben Ashcraft other Roles Played By…

    • Sean Mikesh other Roles Played By…

    Bios and cast slip for Sun, Oct 18, 1:00 PM →

    • Rebecca Hurd as Claudia Yount

      Usually Afra Sophia Tully

    • Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles

    • Ben Ashcraft other Roles Played By…

    • Sean Mikesh other Roles Played By…

    Bios and cast slip for Sun, Oct 18, 7:00 PM →
  32. Saturday, October 17, 2026

    • Rebecca Hurd as Claudia Yount

      Usually Afra Sophia Tully

    • Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles

    • Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Oct 17, 1:00 PM →

    • Rebecca Hurd as Claudia Yount

      Usually Afra Sophia Tully

    • Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles

    • Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…

    Bios and cast slip for Sat, Oct 17, 7:00 PM →
  33. Friday, October 16, 2026

    • Rebecca Hurd as Claudia Yount

      Usually Afra Sophia Tully

    • Quinn Nehr as Lonnie Byers

      Usually John Patrick Collins

    • Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler

      Usually Quinn Nehr

    • Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles

    • Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…

    Bios and cast slip for Fri, Oct 16, 7:00 PM →

Based on published cast-change announcements from At This Playbill. Not every performance or change is recorded. Spotted a mistake or a missing change? Email support@theatreview.app with the show and date.