Stranger Things: The First Shadow cast changes and understudies
Marquis Theatre · Apr 22, 2025 – Jan 3, 2027
44 performances documented between Oct 16, 2026 and Nov 22, 2026. 42 performances had at least one announced change, 185 changes in all.
Cast changes Cast as printed Nothing on record
-
Sunday, November 22, 2026
-
Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
Malcolm Callender select Roles of Sean Mikesh
-
-
Saturday, November 21, 2026
-
Stephen Wattrus as Chief Hopper/Captain Brenner
Usually Ted Koch
-
Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
-
Friday, November 20, 2026
-
Kelsey Anne Brown as Joyce Maldonado
Usually Shea Grant
-
Rebecca Hurd covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles
-
Stephen Wattrus as Chief Hopper/Captain Brenner
Usually Ted Koch
-
Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
Ben Ashcraft select Roles of Sean Mikesh
-
Sean Mikesh select Roles of Ben Ashcraft
-
-
Thursday, November 19, 2026
-
Lia Christina as Alice Creel
Usually Francesca Yhlen
-
Stephen Wattrus as Chief Hopper/Captain Brenner
Usually Ted Koch
-
Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
Rebecca Hurd covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
-
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
-
Nya Garner as Patty Newby
Usually Ayana Cymone
-
Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
Stephen Wattrus as Chief Hopper/Captain Brenner
Usually Ted Koch
-
Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
-
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
-
Nya Garner as Patty Newby
Usually Ayana Cymone
-
Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
Justin Adams as Chief Hopper/Captain Brenner
Usually Ted Koch
-
Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
Drew Redington as Alan Munson
Usually Ben Ashcraft
-
-
Sunday, November 15, 2026
-
Logan Gould as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Ben Ashcraft as Bob Newby
Usually Juan Carlos
-
Neil McCaffrey as Alan Munson
Usually Ben Ashcraft
-
Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
Logan Gould as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Ben Ashcraft as Bob Newby
Usually Juan Carlos
-
Neil McCaffrey as Alan Munson
Usually Ben Ashcraft
-
Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
-
Saturday, November 14, 2026
-
Ben Ashcraft as Bob Newby
Usually Juan Carlos
-
Neil McCaffrey as Alan Munson
Usually Ben Ashcraft
-
Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Logan Gould as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
Malcolm Callender select Roles of Sean Mikesh
-
Logan Gould as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Ben Ashcraft as Bob Newby
Usually Juan Carlos
-
Neil McCaffrey as Alan Munson
Usually Ben Ashcraft
-
Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…
-
-
Friday, November 13, 2026
-
Thursday, November 12, 2026
-
Ben Ashcraft as Bob Newby
Usually Juan Carlos
-
Drew Redington as Alan Munson
Usually Ben Ashcraft
-
Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Malcolm Callender as Charles Sinclair
Usually Robert T. Cunningham
-
Tom D'Agustino as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles
-
-
Wednesday, November 11, 2026
-
Nya Garner as Patty Newby
Usually Ayana Cymone
-
Rebecca Hurd covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Malcolm Callender as Charles Sinclair
Usually Robert T. Cunningham
-
-
Tuesday, November 10, 2026
-
Malcolm Callender as Charles Sinclair
Usually Robert T. Cunningham
-
Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Kelsey Anne Brown as Claudia Yount
Usually Afra Sophia Tully
-
Maya West covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles
-
Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson
Usually Thatcher Jacobs
-
-
Sunday, November 8, 2026
-
Thatcher Jacobs as Henry Creel
Usually Victor de Paula Rocha
-
Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson
Usually Thatcher Jacobs
-
Maya West as Sue Anderson
Usually Zoe Sage
-
Malcolm Callender as Charles Sinclair
Usually Robert T. Cunningham
-
Drew Redington covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
Malcolm Callender as Charles Sinclair
Usually Robert T. Cunningham
-
Drew Redington covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
Maya West as Sue Anderson
Usually Zoe Sage
-
-
Saturday, November 7, 2026
-
Maya West as Sue Anderson
Usually Zoe Sage
-
Rebecca Hurd covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles
-
Drew Redington other Roles Played By…
-
Thatcher Jacobs as Henry Creel
Usually Victor de Paula Rocha
-
Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson
Usually Thatcher Jacobs
-
Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
Nya Garner as Sue Anderson
Usually Zoe Sage
-
Rebecca Hurd covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles
-
Rebecca Hurd covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
Drew Redington other Roles Played By…
-
-
Friday, November 6, 2026
-
Kala Ross as Patty’s Mom
Usually Ta’Rea Campbell
-
Janie Brookshire covering Kala Ross’s roles
-
Maya West as Sue Anderson
Usually Zoe Sage
-
-
Thursday, November 5, 2026
-
Maya West as Sue Anderson
Usually Zoe Sage
-
Stephen Wattrus as Principal Newby
Usually Andrew Hovelson
-
-
Wednesday, November 4, 2026
-
Maya West as Sue Anderson
Usually Zoe Sage
-
-
Tuesday, November 3, 2026
-
Stephen Wattrus as Principal Newby
Usually Andrew Hovelson
-
Maya West as Sue Anderson
Usually Zoe Sage
-
Rebecca Hurd covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
-
Sunday, November 1, 2026
-
Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel
Usually Nick Rehberger
-
Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson
Usually Thatcher Jacobs
-
Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel
Usually Nick Rehberger
-
Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson
Usually Thatcher Jacobs
-
Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
Maya West covering Nya Garner’s roles
-
-
Saturday, October 31, 2026
-
Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel
Usually Nick Rehberger
-
Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson
Usually Thatcher Jacobs
-
Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
Rebecca Hurd as Virginia Creel
Usually Rosie Benton
-
Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel
Usually Nick Rehberger
-
Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson
Usually Thatcher Jacobs
-
Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
-
Friday, October 30, 2026
-
Zoe Sage as Patty Newby
Usually Ayana Cymone
-
Maya West as Sue Anderson
Usually Zoe Sage
-
John Patrick Collins as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson
Usually Thatcher Jacobs
-
Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
-
Thursday, October 29, 2026
-
John Patrick Collins as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
-
Wednesday, October 28, 2026
-
John Patrick Collins as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
-
Tuesday, October 27, 2026
-
John Patrick Collins as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Tom D'Agustino as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Rebecca Hurd as Karen Childress
Usually Taylor Sage Evans
-
Neil McCaffrey as Alan Munson
Usually Ben Ashcraft
-
Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
-
Sunday, October 25, 2026
-
Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
Malcolm Callender covering Sean Mikesh’s roles
-
-
Saturday, October 24, 2026
-
Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel
Usually Nick Rehberger
-
Rebecca Hurd as Karen Childress
Usually Taylor Sage Evans
-
Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…
-
Stephen Wattrus as Victor Creel
Usually Nick Rehberger
-
Rebecca Hurd as Karen Childress
Usually Taylor Sage Evans
-
Drew Redington covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…
-
-
Friday, October 23, 2026
-
Rebecca Hurd as Karen Childress
Usually Taylor Sage Evans
-
Lauren Nicole Cipoletti as Claudia Yount
Usually Afra Sophia Tully
-
Stephen Wattrus covering Justin Adams’s roles
-
-
Thursday, October 22, 2026
-
Rebecca Hurd as Karen Childress
Usually Taylor Sage Evans
-
Maya West covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles
-
Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles
-
-
Wednesday, October 21, 2026
-
Tuesday, October 20, 2026
-
Janie Brookshire as Virginia Creel
Usually Rosie Benton
-
Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Rebecca Hurd covering Kelsey Anne Brown’s roles
-
-
Sunday, October 18, 2026
-
Quinn Nehr as James Hopper, Jr.
Usually Matthew Erick White
-
Rebecca Hurd as Claudia Yount
Usually Afra Sophia Tully
-
Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles
-
Thatcher Jacobs other Roles Played By…
-
Ben Ashcraft other Roles Played By…
-
Sean Mikesh other Roles Played By…
-
Rebecca Hurd as Claudia Yount
Usually Afra Sophia Tully
-
Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles
-
Ben Ashcraft other Roles Played By…
-
Sean Mikesh other Roles Played By…
-
-
Saturday, October 17, 2026
-
Rebecca Hurd as Claudia Yount
Usually Afra Sophia Tully
-
Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles
-
Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…
-
Rebecca Hurd as Claudia Yount
Usually Afra Sophia Tully
-
Drew Redington as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Neil McCaffrey as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles
-
Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…
-
-
Friday, October 16, 2026
-
Rebecca Hurd as Claudia Yount
Usually Afra Sophia Tully
-
Quinn Nehr as Lonnie Byers
Usually John Patrick Collins
-
Drew Redington as Ted Wheeler
Usually Quinn Nehr
-
Neil McCaffrey covering Keller Kennedy’s roles
-
Malcolm Callender other Roles Played By…
-
Based on published cast-change announcements from At This Playbill. Not every performance or change is recorded. Spotted a mistake or a missing change? Email support@theatreview.app with the show and date.