At this performance

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

Marquis Theatre

5 cast changes

  • Thatcher Jacobs as Henry Creel

    Usually Victor de Paula Rocha

    Thatcher Jacobs from Milwaukee, Wisconsin, is proud to make his Broadway debut in Stranger Things: The First Shadow. A student at DePaul pursuing a BFA in acting, Thatcher is best known for his role as Lepus in The Seeding (2023) and Jason in Falsettos Broadway tour (2019).

  • Neil McCaffrey as Walter Henderson

    Usually Thatcher Jacobs

    Neil McCaffrey is upside down to be back on Broadway. Broadway: Billy Elliot, Bye Bye Birdie, Mary Poppins. Regional: The Fantasticks (Flint Rep). Education: UMich MT, LAMDA. Thanks to his friends, family, Carnahan and everyone in the Stranger Things universe! @neilpmc

  • Maya West as Sue Anderson

    Usually Zoe Sage

    Maya West Broadway debut! Born and raised in New York, Maya is a proud alumna of LaGuardia High School. She’s currently pursuing a BFA in theatre and performance at Emerson College. Endless thanks and love to her mom and dad.

  • Malcolm Callender as Charles Sinclair

    Usually Robert T. Cunningham

    Malcolm Callender Broadway debut! Born and raised in The Bronx, Malcolm’s TV credits include Grim Male on “Evil” (Paramount+) and Krank on seasons 3–5 of “Raising Kanan” (Starz). Special I love you to my friends and all my family. @thelandofmac

  • Drew Redington covering Sean Mikesh’s roles

    Drew Redington Broadway: Tony Award-winning revival of Sunset Blvd.; New York, New York; Spamalot; Mean Girls; The Prom; and Holiday Inn. Additional select/television: Chicago Lyric Opera, Paper Mill Playhouse, CBS, NBC and Broadway HD. Training received at Elon University. @drew.redington

The slip

The insert that would have been tucked into the program that night. Print it, or open it in the slip maker to change the wording.

Edit in slip maker

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

At this performance

The role of Henry Creel will be played by Thatcher Jacobs

The role of Walter Henderson will be played by Neil McCaffrey

The role of Sue Anderson will be played by Maya West

The role of Charles Sinclair will be played by Malcolm Callender

The roles usually played by Sean Mikesh will be played by Drew Redington

Marquis Theatre Sunday, November 8, 2026, 1:00 PM

Based on published cast-change announcements from At This Playbill, last read on Nov 18, 2026. Not every performance or change is recorded. Spotted a mistake or a missing change? Email support@theatreview.app with the show and date.